Ungulate personality and the human shield contribute to long-distance migration loss

Long-distance ungulate migrations are declining and past research has focused on preserving migration paths where habitat fragmentation and loss disrupts movement corridors. However, changing residency-migration tradeoffs are the stronger driver of long-distance migration loss in some populations. The human shield effect relative to predation risk and anthropogenic food resources likely shapes these tradeoffs, but individual animals also vary in their propensity to tolerate proximity to humans and developed areas. We investigated how personality relative to human-habituation affects migration behavior. We categorized elk as bold or shy based on use of anthropogenic food resources identified through a clustering algorithm applied to GPS collar data. Bold elk were 4 times more likely to select wintering areas close to human activity and migrated 60% shorter distances compared to shy elk. As a result, elk wintering grounds were spatially structured such that conflict- and disease-prone individuals selected areas adjacent to human activity. Our results suggest that bold personality traits act as a precursor to human-habituation, which permits bold elk to reap the forage and predation rewards that occur in suburban landscapes. A multi-pronged approach beyond just maintaining habitat corridors may be necessary to conserve long-distance migrations for species that can become human-habituated.