Links between magma-tectonic rate balances, plutonism, and volcanism

With Smith's (1979) model of ash flow magmatism as the point of departure, quantitative regimes of crustal magmatic evolution are outlined. The average extrusive regime of ash flow magmatism operates at a rate of about 0.001 km³/yr; progressively larger episodes of increasing repose times characterize the evolution of caldera-forming eruptions. The intrusive regime operates at an inferred average rate of about 0.01 km³/yr expressed in terms of the volumetric influx of mafic magma from the mantle, based on the record of silicic rates of extrusion and a 10:1 intrusive to extrusive ratio derived from evidence of zoned silicic systems. This rate is almost identical with the mean cumulative rate for the Hawaiian-Emperor system of basaltic volcanism, which is determined to be 0.015 km³/yr. Fluctuations about a mean rate of 10⁻² km³/yr lead to a threefold classification of magmatic regimes in terms of source power, depending on whether they are persistently greater than (HHER regime), about equal to (MHER regime), or lower than (LHER regime) the mean Hawaiian-Emperor rate. Ash flow magmatism correlates with the MHER regime, averaged over a sufficiently long time. Thus the conditions of Hawaiian-Emperor magmatism are identified with a characteristic power of magma transfer rates that optimize mechanisms for creation of high-level chambers of derivative and fractionated silicic magma (terminology of Smith (1979)) within sufficiently localized regions of high residence times. These conditions represent a balance point, and a bifurcation, in dynamic paths of magmatic evolution leading to widely divergent types of plutonic-volcanic associations. Categorical examples of the principal types of igneous path are discussed relative to continental basalt, silicic ash flow, batholithic granite, and intrusive porphyry systems. The Henry Mountains, Utah, are thought to represent an example of an intrusive porphyry generated in the LHER regime of a mafic source system lacking sufficient power for volcanic expression or significant mineralization. Long Valley, California (and possibly other systems along the eastern front of the Sierra Nevada), is an example operating at the mean rate with transient excursions to higher and lower rates. In regions of rapid extension and/or volcanic propagation (whether linear or areal) these regimes give rise to basaltic eruptions ranging from isolated cinder cones to flood basalts.